Hello everyone. Flint here, doing an Agent Insights. I'm happy I'm only doing Agent Insights now. I am here to talk about people asking for donations.
"Asking for donations" includes people saying they got scammed/hacked, people saying it's their birthday, people saying they don't have any items, etc. Basically, anything where people ask for things without promising anything in return.
This last part is important. If they don't ask anything in return, it's not really a scam. They didn't deceive you into thinking you'd get something back for your item. When you gave it away, you knew full well you would not get the item back and would get nothing in return. Thus, with few exceptions, people asking for donations are not scams.
You can make a case that people claiming they are new accounts or got scammed or hacked of a certain item are scamming if you discover evidence that they are lying (e.g. they have a bunch of achievements for a new account, they have the item they say got scammed, etc.). In this case, it would be appropriate to make a post/report them for scamming. If you have no evidence that they are lying, you should assume that it is not a scam, or not done maliciously, because there is no way to prove that it is a scam.
We should not make posts about people who we aren't sure are scammers. This is why we don't usually make posts about donations people. It's almost always impossible to tell if they're legit or not, and they don't do anything that involves promising you stuff in return.
You should not give people asking for donations your rares. There is always a chance that they are lying, and even so, it's not good policy to hand out your valuable items to random people. You should instead either ignore them, or give them RIMS or other such not-very-valuable items. This way, you can help people who legitimately just want items, and you won't lose your good items.
Goodbye!